Headphones: Less Than Ideal Hi-Fi Gear?

Even though it was deemed an indispensible component when the Sony Walkman became king back in the 1980s, are headphones, until now, has always been a less than ideal way to listen to music?

By: Ringo Bones

Dubbed by conservatives as the most antisocial way to listen to music back when Sony’s Walkman was new, the shortcomings of the ubiquitous headphones has recently been brought back into the spotlight after the shortcomings of a flagship Apple product – i.e. the Apple AirPods wireless headphones and their Mainland Chinese made knockoffs – as early users complained of excessive background hiss, not to mention early users old enough to remember 1980s era cassette tapes saying that the hiss levels are worse than that of dubbing a copy of a copy of a prerecorded cassette tape album. But are headphones really the weakest link of all the sound producing transducers in our high fidelity audio hobby?

Despite its shortcomings, audio enthusiasts old enough to have taken sound quality seriously back in the 1980s had surprisingly managed to make due of listening to music via headphones. Weird between-the-ears stereo soundstage when listening to plain vanilla 2-channel stereo cassette recordings and producing more background hiss in comparison to conventional loudspeakers notwithstanding. But let us explore more on the headphone’s hiss issue given that, especially when listening to prerecorded cassette tape albums as your primary music source, is already inherently hissy in the first place.

Hiss is more noticeable through headphones than speakers for several reasons. Since headphones lie closer to the ears of the listener in comparison to loudspeakers, any hiss that the headphones’ produce is readily transferred to the eardrums. Headphones are more sensitive than loudspeakers – i.e. headphone sensitivity are typically measured in decibels per milliwatt as opposed to decibels per watt when measuring loudspeaker sensitivity – so headphones are more likely to pick-up the faint residual hiss produced by your audio rig, like that in the preamplifier stage. And headphone models that isolate your ears from outside sounds can also prevent such sounds from masking hiss, denying the user from using Mother Nature’s naturally generated dither noise.