Known for its “chrome-plated hi-fi sound” when used in non
electric guitar reverb applications, is the 12AT7 / ECC81 vacuum tube more
suited for electric guitar reverb amps than for hi-fi audio applications?
By: Ringo Bones
The 12AT7 small signal / preamplifier vacuum tube – also
known in Europe by the Mullard-Philips vacuum tube designation as the ECC81. It
is a miniature 9-pin medium gain (60 V/V) dual triode vacuum tube on a B9A base
with 12.6V / 6.3V series / parallel heater. It didn’t really catch on as an
high fidelity audio vacuum tube despite being indispensible in electric guitar
reverb amplifier applications like the Fullerton based circuitry of Tweed era
Fender amps – though the older stand alone electric guitar reverb units use 6K6
vacuum tubes instead of the 12AT7.
On the topic of nichrome wire spring and fine wire wound
moving iron reverb assemblies that are de rigueur in post World War II era
electric guitar amplifier reverbs can be skillfully cobbled up by those still
dexterous enough to be able to wound fine wire into their DIY moving coil
cartridge for vinyl LP replay have an inherent high frequency roll-off due to
inductive losses and stray capacitance in the reverb tank winding assemblies.
The 12AT7 and ECC81 vacuum tubes primarily serve as pre-emphasis high frequency
boosting circuits to counter the high frequency losses of spring reverb
assemblies in order to obtain a more or less flat frequency response across the
audio spectrum. Compared to bucket-brigade device (BBD) integrated circuit
assemblies intended to replace the spring reverb during the 1980s -electric
guitar spring reverb amplifiers have a much better sound quality and can reach
20,000Hz compared to those Godawful sounding BBD based reverb systems – while I.C. based BBD sound very awful and dull and has a bandwidth
of only 5,000 Hz.
The 12AT7 / ECC81 belongs to a large family of small signal
dual triode preamplifier vacuum tubes which share the same pin-out – EIA 9A –
including the very commonly used low mu 12AU7 / ECC82 and the ubiquitous
high-mu 12AX7 / ECC83 small signal
vacuum tube. The 12AT7 has a somewhat lower voltage gain than the 12AX7 but has
a higher transconductance and plate current ratings which make it suitable for
high frequency applications.
Even though it didn’t really catch on as a high fidelity
audio preamplifier vacuum tube when it was originally released back in May 20,
1947 by the American vacuum tube manufacturer General Electric – the 12AT7
vacuum tube was originally intended for operation in VHF circuits such as TV
sets and FM tuners as an oscillator / frequency converter, but it also found
wide use in audio as a driver and phase inverter in vacuum tube push pull audio
power amplifier circuits. In old vacuum tube data books from the 1950s, the
12AT7 / ECC81 tube is actually listed as a VHF type. Its highish mutual
conductance of 5.5mA/V together with its high amplification factor makes it
ideal as a cathode follower / unity gain buffer or cathode coupled phase
splitter. Other versions of the 12AT7 / ECC81 vacuum tube include the 6201 US
DoD military version, 6060 special quality version, the B309 by GEC and the ECC85
which is very similar but has a different pinout.
The 12AT7 / ECC81 has a much higher gm than the 12AX7 /
ECC83 so gains in the region of 40 can be achieved with a single section even
though its mu is only 55. The 12AT7 / ECC81 will also work well as a cascode or
at low voltages at Va = 75Volts and its noise is low. The lowered anode
impedance allows the 12AT7 / ECC81 to have a better high frequency response
than the 12AX7 / ECC83 and better drive capability. Linearity isn’t really the
12AT7 vacuum tube’s forte though so most audio engineers won’t recommend it in
very high level applications such as driving power triode vacuum tubes.
The sound quality of a typical 12AT7 / ECC81 vacuum tube is
like a chrome plated version of the 12AX7 / ECC83 vacuum tube – with a bright,
almost metallic upper midrange and much less of the 12AX7 / ECC83’s warmth
making the 12AT7 more suited to electric guitar spring reverb preamplifier
applications. Some people adore the 12AT7 tube’s inherently bright metallic
sound and they are often a staple of vacuum tube power amps by Tube Technology
known for their bright-sounding vacuum tube based audio gear and the iconic
British “valve amp” manufacturer Beard.
4 comments:
The "chrome plated" sound quality of a typical 12AT7 vacuum tube will probably work for its favor in electric guitar spring reverb applications due to inherent inductive losses of nickel chrome spring reverbs that make them sound inherently dull when using a 12AX7 vacuum tube.
Not only in the inherently inductive nickel-chromium spring reverb units used in electric guitar applications which roll-off high frequencies like cray - though I still very much prefer their sound quality over those God-Awful sounding bucket-brigade device / BBD chips / integrated circuit based reverbs that can't play anything above 5,000 Hz - a badly wound interstage transformer transformer with an excess of stray capacitance in its windings also rolloff high frequencies like crazy, thus necessitating the inherently "chrome plated / bright" sound quality of the 12AT7 vacuum tube and its European ECC81 variant.
Interstage transformers with a good square-wave response have virtually zero stray capacitance to maintain good high frequency output. Should one use Nobu Shishito's inverted interstage transformers?
Transformers - whether interstage transformers or output transformers - are very important in vacuum tube audio preamplifiers and power amplifiers. One whose windings have an excess of stray capacitance could either act as a load - in the case of output transformers - hogging and diverting the output signal intended for the speakers or cause parasitic oscillation that could result in motorboating and other audio circuit related nasties. Having a dull sound is the least of the problems of an improperly wound output or interstage transformer. Having a very good to exemplar square wave response seems to be a prerequisite in 21st Century era vacuum tube audio amplification circuits.
Post a Comment